BreedCover may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. How we make money

Last updated: November 2026

Accident-only vs accident-and-illness plans, explained with care

Two quotes can look like the same protection at very different prices, and the difference is one plain line: an accident-only plan covers sudden injuries and never covers illness, while an accident-and-illness plan covers injuries and sickness together. On NAPHIA 2024 averages, accident-only costs $16.10 a month for dogs and $9.17 for cats, against $62.44 and $32.21 for accident-and-illness. This guide shows what each plan covers, who each one honestly fits, and why changing your mind later is not a clean upgrade for the pet you love, on the hardest days of all, in sickness and in injury alike, for years to come.

The quick answer

Accident-only covers sudden injuries like broken bones, bite wounds, swallowed objects, and poisoning, and it never covers illness. Accident-and-illness covers those same injuries plus illnesses like cancer, infections, allergies, and diabetes. On NAPHIA 2024 averages, accident-only is $16.10 a month for dogs and $9.17 a month for cats, against $62.44 and $32.21 for accident-and-illness. The lower premium buys a much smaller promise, and the sections below show exactly where that promise ends.

The two plans, in the industry definitions

These are industry categories, not names invented by one insurer. NAPHIA, the North American Pet Health Insurance Association, describes accident-only with examples like foreign body ingestion, lacerations, motor vehicle accidents, ligament tears, and poisoning, and describes accident-and-illness as accident benefits plus illnesses such as cancer, infections, and digestive problems. NerdWallet puts the same line in plain words: accident-only plans pay to treat accidental injuries, and they will not cover expenses due to cancer, infections, or other illnesses. Not every insurer sells an accident-only plan, which is part of the comparison below.

What accident-only covers

An accident, in the insurer wording ASPCA Pet Health Insurance uses, is a sudden, unpreventable event that causes physical injury, with examples like car accidents, falls, snake bites, and stepping on glass. Its accident-only page covers bite wounds, broken bones, swallowed objects, and toxic ingestions, plus the diagnostics and treatment prescribed for an accident: X-rays, MRI, ultrasounds, blood work, sutures, medications, hospitalization, and surgery. NerdWallet lists the same shape for both plan types: animal bites, bee stings, broken bones, car accidents, cuts or lacerations, eye injuries, fractured teeth, poisoning, ruptured ligaments, swallowing a foreign object, and torn nails. Your own policy defines what counts as an accident, so read that definition before you rely on any single item here.

What accident-only never covers

This is the center of the page, so it is printed plainly. Accident-only never covers illness: no cancer, no infections, no allergies, no diabetes, no kidney or heart disease, no ear or urinary infections, and no chronic condition, however suddenly it appears. Sudden is not the test. An infection or a urinary blockage that strikes overnight is still illness. ASPCA answers the question directly on its own page: no, its accident-only plan does not cover illnesses, and its not-covered list adds hereditary conditions, behavioral issues, dental illness, and preventive care, along with pre-existing conditions. Embrace lists the same exclusions for its accident-only plan: illnesses, breed-specific and genetic conditions, congenital conditions, chronic conditions, cancer, and dental illness are not covered.

What accident-and-illness adds

Accident-and-illness starts from the same accident list and adds the sickness side of a pet life. NerdWallet lists allergies, arthritis, cancer, diabetes, ear infections, heart disease, kidney disease, skin conditions, thyroid disorders, urinary tract infections, and vomiting and diarrhea. Spot describes its accident-and-illness plan the same way: help with accidents and with future illnesses that may require ongoing care, like infections, allergies, or age-related concerns, while its accident-only plan does not cover illnesses or routine checkups. Hereditary and congenital conditions sit on this side of the line in a qualified form: many accident-and-illness plans cover them when signs did not show before enrollment, while the accident-only plans named above exclude them by name.

What each plan costs, on one labeled dataset

Plan type, NAPHIA 2024 U.S. averageDogs, per monthCats, per month
Accident-only$16.10$9.17
Accident-and-illness$62.44$32.21

NAPHIA publishes both averages directly, in annual form in its State of the Industry Report, and ConsumerVoice reports the same 2024 NAPHIA data in the monthly form printed here. The arithmetic a reader will do anyway is simple subtraction on those labeled averages: the dog gap is $46.34 a month and the cat gap is $23.04 a month. That gap is not a saving on the same protection. It is the price of the illness promise described in the section above, and a family quote will differ from any average here by pet, place, deductible, reimbursement rate, and annual limit. Our pet insurance cost guide works through what moves a real quote.

Who sells which plan

Plan menus change, so this page names only the overlap a reader can rely on across the comparison guides read for it. ASPCA, Spot, Pets Best, AKC, and Hartville sell accident-only plans alongside accident-and-illness plans, and Embrace sells accident-only in the senior form described below. NerdWallet lists those names among its accident-only sellers, and MoneyGeek names ASPCA, Spot, and Hartville as its top accident-only picks. One flat-rate example prints with its label: Canine Journal reports Pets Best accident-only at $9 a month for dogs and $6 a month for cats regardless of age or breed, and the Farmers pet insurance page for Pets Best plans states the same flat form, with Washington state at $10 and $7 in its note. No other insurer-specific premium prints on this page.

Waiting periods: one clock or more

An accident-only plan has one clock to wait out, because illness cover never begins on it. An accident-and-illness plan has more clocks, for accidents, for illnesses, and often a long one for orthopedic conditions. Named accident-clock examples from the Canine Journal comparison table are ASPCA at 14 days, Pets Best at 3 days, AKC at 2 days, Spot at 14 days, and Nationwide at 14 days, and MoneyGeek independently gives ASPCA, Spot, and Hartville at 14 days for accidents. Those are examples that vary by state and plan, not promises. Our pet insurance waiting periods guide sets out the full three-clock story, including the state rules that can shorten the clocks.

Older pets and accident-only

Both halves of this story belong together. At Embrace, dogs and cats aged 15 years and over can be enrolled in its accident-only plan, on fixed terms of up to $5,000 a year, a $100 annual deductible, and 90% reimbursement, while a pet enrolled younger keeps the cover already in force. NerdWallet notes the wider shape: in some cases, accident-only may be the only option for a pet too old at enrollment to qualify for an accident-and-illness policy at a given insurer. The counterpoint matters just as much: ASPCA states no upper age limit that forces a pet into accident-only cover, and the insurer-site check behind our senior guide lists Spot, Pets Best, Figo, MetLife, Fetch, Pumpkin, and ASPCA as stating no upper enrollment age on their own sites. An older pet may still enroll in accident-and-illness cover at those insurers, at senior pricing and with everything already in the record excluded as pre-existing. Our pet insurance for senior dogs guide works through that choice in full.

Where the line gets drawn in a real policy

A torn cruciate ligament shows why definitions matter more than plan names. Canine Journal reports that Pets Best accident-only covers many of the same items as other providers except for torn ligaments, and its comparison table marks cruciate ligament cover as not covered for Pets Best, AKC, and Nationwide accident-only plans, against a 14 day wait at ASPCA and Spot. A second comparison guide makes the reason plain: a cruciate entry is marked check the wording, because ligament problems can develop gradually rather than from a single event, and may be treated as illness or given their own waiting period. The same torn ligament can be a covered accident, a long-wait condition, or not covered at all, depending on the plan in front of you. Check the ligament wording before you enroll, in the sample policy itself.

What neither plan covers

Neither plan type covers routine care, and neither covers what is already there. NerdWallet lists pre-existing conditions, cosmetic or elective procedures, breeding, and routine care as excluded from both accident-and-illness and accident-only plans. Canine Journal states the same routine-care line: neither plan type includes preventive care like vaccines, preventive medications, or spay and neuter procedures, and no pet insurance covers pre-existing conditions immediately after enrollment. A wellness add-on is a separate purchase on top of either plan type at some insurers, and ASPCA offers preventive care as an add-on to its accident-only plan. A no-wait wellness benefit never means no-wait insurance cover. Our how pet insurance works guide and our wellness and preventive care plans guide explain both parts in full.

If you think you will want illness cover later

Changing your mind later is not a clean upgrade. Spot explains, in its guidance on changing a policy, that changing cover can mean cancelling and re-enrolling, with a new waiting period, and conditions from the earlier policy or the waiting period would be considered pre-existing, with changes subject to underwriting and approval. NerdWallet gives the same warning in buyer terms: if a family increases coverage limits, some companies treat it as a whole new plan, waiting periods may start over, and conditions the policy previously covered can be considered pre-existing going forward. So choose illness cover while a pet is young and healthy if the family thinks they will want it, because a diagnosis that arrives during accident-only years does not become covered by upgrading afterward. Our puppy insurance guide tells that enrollment-timing story from the start of a pet life.

Which plan fits your pet

MoneyGeek describes accident-only as more likely to fit a pet at higher risk of accidental injury, a pet whose pre-existing illnesses would be excluded in any case, a family focused on protection against a large unexpected emergency bill, and a senior pet with fewer comprehensive options. NerdWallet adds the family that cannot stretch to accident-and-illness premiums but still wants some emergency protection. Then ask the mirror question plainly, because it is the question this whole page leads to: if this pet were diagnosed with cancer, diabetes, or a kidney condition next year, could the family pay for that care themselves, month after month? If the honest answer is no, accident-only is not enough protection for that pet, whatever the premium difference above. No plan here is the right choice for every family. The right choice is the one that still protects the dog or cat you love on the day illness, not only injury, arrives. For pets beyond dogs and cats, our exotic pet insurance basics guide sets out how plan types work for less common pets.

Frequently asked questions

Does accident-only pet insurance cover illness?

No. Accident-only covers eligible expenses for accidents and unexpected injuries only. ASPCA states that plainly on its own accident-only page, and Embrace lists illnesses, cancer, chronic conditions, congenital and genetic conditions, and dental illness as not covered on its accident-only plan.

How much cheaper is accident-only than accident-and-illness?

On NAPHIA 2024 U.S. averages, accident-only is $16.10 a month for dogs and $9.17 for cats, against $62.44 and $32.21 for accident-and-illness. The gap is $46.34 a month for dogs and $23.04 for cats on those averages, and it buys a much smaller promise: injuries only, never illness.

Can I upgrade from accident-only to accident-and-illness later?

Not cleanly. Spot explains that changing cover can mean cancelling and re-enrolling, with a new waiting period and earlier conditions treated as pre-existing. NerdWallet warns the same way: some companies treat a coverage increase as a whole new plan, waiting periods may start over, and previously covered conditions can become pre-existing.

Is accident-only the only insurance a senior dog or cat can get?

Not everywhere. At Embrace, a new enrollment at 15 years or older is accident-only, on fixed terms of up to $5,000 a year, a $100 deductible, and 90% reimbursement. ASPCA states no upper age limit forcing accident-only, and Spot, Pets Best, Figo, MetLife, Fetch, Pumpkin, and ASPCA state no upper enrollment age on their own sites.

Does accident-only cover a torn cruciate ligament?

It depends on the plan. Canine Journal marks cruciate ligament cover as not covered on Pets Best, AKC, and Nationwide accident-only plans, against a 14 day wait at ASPCA and Spot, and notes Pets Best accident-only excepts torn ligaments. Check the ligament wording in the sample policy before enrolling.

Does either plan cover vaccines and checkups?

No. NerdWallet lists routine care as excluded from both plan types, and Canine Journal states that neither includes preventive care like vaccines, preventive medications, or spay and neuter procedures. A wellness add-on is a separate purchase at some insurers.

Compare quotes for your pet

Premiums vary by breed, age, and zip code. The only way to know your price is to run real quotes - it takes about two minutes.